Feb 22, 2018 Last Updated 11:17 PM, Feb 21, 2018

Review: Beyond decent work

Garment workers working at a factory
Published: Jun 01, 2017

 

A new book examines Indonesian labour struggles through the lens of international political economy theory

 

Indonesian wages continue to be among the lowest in the region. The term ‘decent work’ is generally defined as fair globalisation and poverty reduction through the promotion of competitiveness. This is achieved by improving compliance with existing labour regulations. But more radical unions in Indonesia have decided not to be part of ‘decent work’ schemes at all.  In his book Beyond decent work: The cultural political economy of labour struggles in Indonesia, Felix Hauf argues that it remains questionable whether low-cost production can ever be compatible with ethical labour standards given that the Indonesian minimum wage (which is not even paid by many employers) is seldom above subsidence levels.

Hauf’s book is first and foremost concerned with whether or not ‘decent work discourse’ is helping Indonesian unions in their political strategies and everyday struggles for better living and working condition for workers, and if so, how.

Over the course of the book, Hauf develops a more critical understanding of what ‘decent work’ actually stands for. In many ways ‘decent work’ schemes simply act to boost the public image of transnational corporations and represent only cosmetic changes in line with their corporate social responsibility activities. They are rarely intended to bring fundamental change to the economic imbalance experienced by workers in the global South, but are merely ‘strategies aiming to humanise neoliberal capitalism’.

In order to evaluate the impacts of ‘decent work’ schemes in Indonesia, Hauf examines three case studies in the garment and textile industries, which are among the most globalised sectors in Indonesia. Before revealing his findings Hauf offers a detailed examination of his theoretical framing, cultural political economy, and his methodological approach, referred to as critical grounded theory. He engages with the prominent writers of post-Marxist thought, such as Gramsci and Poulantzas and the usual big names from French poststructuralist philosophy. The works of Bob Jessop and Ngai-Ling Sum, who have thoughtfully dissected the flaws of late capitalism and neoliberal globalisation, are Hauf’s key references.

Passages in the book on the downfall of Atlantic Fordism in the West and the Keynesian welfare state are not without interest, but they are not particularly relevant to Indonesia, as the history of labour in that country is quite different. Hauf's theoretical thinking on labour regulation is mostly suitable, but what is missing from his cultural political economy analysis is its economic component.

Whilst outlined briefly in Chapter 5 with the help of the writings of La Botz and Ford, more emphasis was also needed on the specifics of Indonesia’s case, its macro-economic developments since independence and the history of unionism. The addition of detail on income structure, unemployment/underemployment and living standards in contemporary Indonesia would have been helpful to those readers who are not Indonesia experts. One gains the impression that, in this book, Indonesia is simply a case study to serve as a vehicle for wishful thinking, particularly when it comes to detecting the counter-hegemonic struggles of unionists that might spark revolutionary changes in the labour sector. 

This wishful thinking was particularly obvious at the end of Chapter 7, in which Hauf describes two cases of counter-hegemonic struggle in Indonesia. The first the short-lived occupation of a factory (PT Istana) and the second the cooperative cultivation of coffee in Java. Hauf’s reasoning reads: ‘Although the factory occupation at PT Istana can hardly be called a success story of industrial production under workers’ control, it clearly shows that there are radical alternatives envisioned and enacted by Indonesian garment workers and their unions’. Both cases might be categorised as counter-hegemonic discourse, but deducing from them (and from a number of large strikes that took place in 2012) a much broader reaction to the so-called crisis of capitalism, appears naïve. It ignores other developments in Indonesia’s labour and employment sector in which price dumping and labour flexibility have reached new levels, as evidenced by the success of Go-Jek, an app-based motorcycle taxi service and all its latest related service offers.

Hauf spent several months in Indonesia on fieldwork in 2011 and 2012, during which time he conducted a number of semi-structured interviews with representatives of the International Labour Organisation (ILO) and different Indonesian unions. He described this ‘ethnographic immersion into the field’ as ‘fundamental’, as ‘the researcher employs pre-concepts to better understand how discourses and imaginaries become practically relevant in people’s everyday lives’. However, it is not entirely clear where (presumably in Jakarta) and in what surroundings those interviews took place, or how the informants were chosen, other than with the help of snowballing and according to their availability and interest in participating in his study. Here, it might have been interesting to investigate and discuss more thoroughly the cases of those informants who declined to participate, which can often be a rather insightful exercise. Although Hauf claims that his fieldwork was ethnographic – a claim often encountered outside of anthropology – there appeared to have been little use of Indonesian-language sources and ethnographic material. 

The empirical contribution of Hauf’s book is its critical analysis of two major campaigns that supposedly serve the ‘decent work’ agenda. The first of these was ‘Better Work Indonesia’, an approach based on the Cambodian Better Factory Scheme and introduced to Indonesia as a monitoring project during the ILO’s targeting of the garment industry in 2011, where they promoted competitiveness by improving legal compliance. The second case study was the ‘Play Fair Alliance’, an 18-month negotiation process between unions, factory management and international sports brands such as Nike and Adidas, which led to the signing of the Freedom of Association Protocol. Hauf characterises ‘Better Work Indonesia’ as ‘hegemonic “decent work from above” imaginary’. ‘Play Fair Alliance’, on the other hand, he characterises as ‘sub-hegemonic “decent work from below” imaginary’ because it changes the hegemonic codes of neoliberal labour regulation in important ways, especially with regard to active participation in unions. 

Hauf ends with a strong plea for an alternative economy, a ‘“solidarity economy” [that] provides alternative employment opportunities … [and] new forms of identity and class consciousness’. Although reading this book sometimes requires strenuous effort, Hauf has shown that he has outstanding analytical skills and is definitely an author to look out for in the future.

 

 

Felix Hauf, Beyond Decent Work: The Cultural Political Economy of Labour Struggles in Indonesia. Frankfurt/New York: Campus, 2016.

 

Antje Missbach (antje.missbach@monash.edu) is a senior research fellow at Monash University, Melbourne.

 

Related articles from the archive
     

Nov 06, 2016
The Go-Jek effect by Michele Ford and Vivian Honan
Has this phenomenally successful app-based transport service improved the lives of the motorcycle workers it employs?

 

Jan 27, 2016
United in disappointment by Teri L Caraway and Michele Ford
Labour rights have suffered under the Jokowi administration

 

Dec 09, 2012
A new tactical toolkit by Rachelle Cole
The labour movement successfully adopted new tactics in their campaign for social security reform

 

Inside Indonesia 128: Apr-Jun 2017

Latest Articles

Diplomasi pendopo dan gamelan sekar laras

Feb 16, 2018 - DUNCAN GRAHAM

Crossing the finish line

Feb 13, 2018 - JOSH STENBERG 2

Wilson Tjandinegara (photo courtesy of Guoji Ribao)

Bilingual Chinese-Indonesian writer Wilson Tjandinegara built bridges within Indonesia’s literary culture

A showcase of harmony

Feb 13, 2018 - JOSH STENBERG

The Leyun Choir (樂韻合唱團) performs

Celebrating Indonesia’s birthday with the Mandarin choirs of Jakarta

Review: Ending the silence

Feb 07, 2018 - JOOST COTE

Social exclusion in a state urban mega-development

Feb 01, 2018 - SARAH MOSER & ALYSSA WILBUR

Multi-generational villagers’ land and homes are being expropriated for the new capital  Credit: Alyssa Shamsa Wilbur

Indonesia’s first new city, like many others, may not be addressing the urban problems it was supposed to 

Subscribe to Inside Indonesia

Receive Inside Indonesia's latest articles and quarterly editions in your inbox.

 


Lontar Modern Indonesia

Lontar-Logo-Ok

 

A selection of stories from the Indonesian classics and modern writers, periodically published free for Inside Indonesia readers, courtesy of Lontar

30th Anniversary Book

Inside Indonesia - 30th Anniversary Photo Book

 

Have you bought your copy of Inside Indonesia's 30th Anniversary book yet?

The book features 30 of the judges' favourite images from the 2013 Inside Indonesia Photography Competition.

Preview the book  and order your copy online (Soft cover approx AUD$23.00 / Hard cover approx AUD$35.00).