Aug 10, 2020 Last Updated 3:42 AM, Aug 7, 2020

Breaking free in gay Paris

Published: Jan 20, 2020
Versi Bh. Indonesia

Wisnu Adihartono

Being a gay person in Indonesia is not easy. Many Indonesians believe that being gay is a disease and that violence against gay men is acceptable. Since 2016, the situation for gay men has become worse. As a result, some gay men who have the resources leave Indonesia for other countries, including France. As part of my PhD research in France, I interviewed 25 gay Indonesian men living in Paris. All names are pseudonyms.

In Paris there are number of gay hangouts, such as Le Marais and the area around Hôtel de Ville. Gay men I met there told me they had found a sense of freedom and belonging that they could only dream of in Indonesia.

When Bambang finished high school in Yogyakarta, he successfully applied for a university scholarship in Paris. He said:

‘I don’t know why Paris. What I do know, because I speak French, is that French is a sexy language. Before leaving, I imagined Paris as the city of the Eiffel Tower. That's all I knew.’

When Bambang arrived in Paris he did not know if it was a gay-friendly city. But after five years of living there, and after coming out as gay, he said he felt a sense of freedom and acceptance that he could not find in Indonesia. Now with a French boyfriend, Bambang knows he can’t return to Indonesia:

‘Indonesia is not a country for LGBT people. We were discriminated against. Just look at Aceh. It’s terrible. If the Indonesian government is willing to change the regulations, we will return.’

Gay life in Paris

Hendri has lived in Paris for several years. He says he has relationships with French men, not Indonesian men.

‘I prefer to hang out with French gays. Why? I find gay Indonesians lie and talk about meaningless things (mengatakan yang tidak-tidak). I only meet other Indonesians when there is an event at the Indonesian Embassy.’

One of the tensions that can arise in relationships between Indonesian men is the issue of religion. Some participants told me that they prefer relationships with French men because then they don’t argue about religion. For instance, Adi said he prefers to date French men who do not have a religion.

‘Indonesian people are hypocritical when talking about religion. They say everything is taboo or forbidden, and that God created only men and women. But what about lesbian, gay and transgender people?’

Abimanyu said that he felt France was more tolerant of religious diversity than Indonesia:

‘I am a Muslim and I often go to Christian events here in Paris. We do not feel disturbed by such things. I hope that this also happens in Indonesia. But I think it does not. I see on the internet that violence in the name of religion is increasing in Indonesia.’

There is racism and homophobia in France but Abimanyu believes that it is a more tolerant place than Indonesia.

The men I met were keen to present a good image of France, and they said that they were respected for being gay. For instance, Sa’id said:

‘French people are respectful of men, women, gays, lesbians and even trans people. Although sometimes I see on television or read in the newspaper there is harassment against people like us, it is nothing compared to what happens in Indonesia. I am also happy that French people do not ask about your religion. For them, religion is a sensitive and private matter.’

Even though the gay men I met in Paris are sad that they are far from family and friends, they like the fact that they can live openly as gay men. As persecution is increasing for LGBT people in Indonesia it is unlikely they will return in the near future.

Wisnu Adihartono completed his PhD in Sociology at the Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales (EHESS) in Marseille, France. Now he is an independent researcher in Jakarta.

Inside Indonesia 139: Jan-Mar 2020

Latest Articles

A generation of resistance

Jun 26, 2020 - IVO MATEUS GONCALVES

Students demonstrate at Santa Cruz cemetery, 12 November 1991 / Author

East Timor’s student movement and the struggle against oppression

Essay: Celebrating Imlek, Catholic style

Jun 22, 2020 - JOSH STENBERG

/ Josh Stenberg

Practices such as Imlek masses are a welcome example of tolerance and plurality

West Papua and Black Lives Matter

Jun 17, 2020 - SOPHIE CHAO

We are not monkeys / Twitter

A movement seeking justice, healing, and freedom for Black people has become a powerful rallying call for Indigenous West Papuans

Artists seek assistance

Jun 14, 2020 - RAHMADI FAJAR HIMAWAN

Several pesinden accompanying a wayang performance / Rahmadi Fajar Himawan

Javanese traditional musicians are among the many artists and performers struggling to survive, or qualify for government payments under COVID restrictions

A house of cards?

Jun 02, 2020 - YULIDA PANGASTUTI

ANTARA FOTO/Saiful Bahri/wsj

The COVID-19 crisis has highlighted the exploitation of non-formal early childhood educators 

Subscribe to Inside Indonesia

Receive Inside Indonesia's latest articles and quarterly editions in your inbox.

 


Lontar Modern Indonesia

Lontar-Logo-Ok

 

A selection of stories from the Indonesian classics and modern writers, periodically published free for Inside Indonesia readers, courtesy of Lontar